PDA

View Full Version : Alternate Timeline of 1989 for T2k (all editions)


Raellus
05-20-2023, 04:39 PM
For fans of v1's History Chronology, such as myself, the divergence of the T2k temporal continuum from actual history is a bit of a sticking point. One has to ignore major real-world events from 1989-1991 in order to arrive at an extant Soviet Union and Warsaw Pact. Furthermore, for some fans of 4e's History Chronology, there's a twinge of dissatisfaction that it results in a USSR with no major European allies, and most of the former members of the Warsaw Pact aligned with NATO.

This alternate timeline seeks to remedy both of those issues by positing a alternate reality branch from actual history in the pivotal year of 1989. This addresses the various Velvet Revolutions and explains why the fall of the Iron Curtain, the dissolution and subsequent realignment of the Warsaw Pact nations, and the end of the Soviet Union, do not occur.

I've deliberately ended the timeline at the end of 1989, skipping ahead to where the canonical v1 Chronology History officially begins in 1995. I am, however, working on a short addendum addressing Desert Shield/Storm/Saber in 1991.

As this is a first draft, constructive feedback is welcome.

NOTE: Actual historical events are presented in plain text. Alternate history events are italicized.

R.I.P. David Hasselhoff


Twilight 2000 Alternate 1989 Timeline

February

“Round Table Talks” between the outlawed Solidarity Labor Union and the Polish communist government begin. Free and open parliamentary elections are agreed in principle, and tentatively scheduled to occur in April.
On the 15th, Soviet 40th Army completes its withdrawal from Afghanistan, ending the Soviet Union’s costly and increasingly unpopular decade-long Afghan War.

March

Growing dissatisfaction with Soviet president Mikhail Gorbachev’s leadership in the Stavka and state intelligence services results in the forming of a secret cabal later known to history as Krasnaya Vesna (Red Spring). Among the hard-liners, Gorbachev is seen as being weak and ideologically impure. They conclude that his continued leadership will ultimately result in the dissolution of the Soviet Empire in Europe, and the end of Russian hegemony. Preliminary planning for replacement of the USSR’s current civilian government begins in secret. Soviet intelligence services are tasked with evaluating the loyalty of high-ranking Soviet and Warsaw Pact government and military officers.

May 14

Gorbachev visits China, the first Soviet leader to do so since the 1963 Sino-Soviet split. Red Spring plotters discuss placing a bomb on Gorbachev’s plane and detonating it during the return trip, or arresting him when he lands back in the USSR. These ideas, however, are discarded, as preparations to install a successor government are nowhere near complete.

May 17
Chinese students begin pro-democracy demonstrations in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square.

June 4

Solidarity-backed candidates win an overwhelming majority in Poland’s first free and open elections.

June 4-5

Chinese troops crush the student demonstrations in Tiananmen Square, sparking worldwide outrage. The Red Spring plotters take note of the West’s rather anemic response to the Chinese government’s violent crackdown on internal dissent.

August 19

Austrian and Hungarian citizens meet at the border for the peaceful anti-Soviet “Pan European Picnic” protest.

August 21

In Poland, Tadeuz Mazowiecki becomes the first non-communist prime minister since 1945 in all of Eastern Europe.

August 23

Pro-independence citizens of Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania form a human chain, dubbed the “Baltic Way”, spanning all three Baltic Soviet Republics.

September

The Red Spring Plotters watch events in Eastern Europe with a growing sense of urgency. Much, but not all, of the ground work for a coup has been laid. The Red Spring plotters select October 25th, the 72nd anniversary of the Russian Revolution, as target date for removing Gorbachev from office and installing a hard-line “interim” government. Rumors of an impending coup have reached Gorbachev but he dismisses them as fear-mongering and political provocation.

October

Pro-democracy protests begin in the East German city of Leipzig. Red Spring decides to postpone the coup by a few weeks, as the conspiracy has yet to secure the cooperation of several key Warsaw Pact military officers.

November 4

One million East Germans gather in Berlin’s Alexanderplatz to protest communist party rule.

November 5

Growing pro-democracy protests on both sides of the Berlin Wall… force Red Spring’s hand. On Monday, November 5th, Gorbachev is seized by Spetsnaz commandos and placed under house arrest at a dacha outside of Moscow. Tanks surround the Kremlin and the Moscow White House (meeting place of the People’s Control Committee and Supreme Soviet of Russia) and Red Spring-allied government officials declare a national state of emergency, granting themselves and the military cabal sweeping powers. The Supreme Soviet of the USSR is suspended and pro-Gorbachev members are arrested on charges of treason. A purge of the Soviet government and military begins.
At the outset of the coup, Soviet military forces in Eastern Europe and the restive SSR’s are put on high alert. Select units are ordered to assist collaborationist WTO military forces in disarming “reactionary elements”. Goaded on by Red Spring-affiliated military liaisons from the Soviet Northern Group of Forces, a parallel cabal of Polish military officers launches its own coup, surrounding the Polish parliament building in Warsaw with armored vehicles. Thousands of protestors spontaneously take to the streets, hurling bricks and Molotov cocktails at the coup forces. The “reactionary rioters” are met with deadly force.

On Monday night, pro-democracy demonstrators in East Berlin are scattered by tear gas, tank treads, and bullets. Some East German border guards attempt to intervene on behalf of the civilian protestors and are cut down by pro-coup Soviet and DDR forces. When the shooting starts, American actor-singer David Hasselhoff is stuck atop an elevated platform on the west side of the Wall after the crane’s hoist mechanism malfunctions. He is hit in the head by a stray round fired from the east side of the wall and killed instantly.
Many world governments strenuously condemn the Soviet military coup and subsequent collaborationist crackdowns in Eastern Europe. Some Communist states, however, praise the Red Spring plotters’ actions. NATO discusses taking military action. The West German representatives, in particular, are shocked and incensed by the bloodshed on the east side of the Berlin Wall. After much deliberation, NATO demurs, raising its military readiness levels but refusing to take direct military action, lest it unintentionally start World War III.

The PRC government, having recently dealt heavy-handedly with China’s own pro-democracy demonstrations, initially issues a statement of support for Red Spring. Subsequent PRC purchases of Soviet military hardware, oil, and natural gas help keep the USSR’s moribund economy afloat.

December

In its largest operation since the Vietnam War, the US military launches Operation Just Cause, to remove Panamanian dictator Manuel Noriega from power and bring him to trial on trial on drug trafficking charges (his deepening relationship with Cuba, and arms deals with various Warsaw Pact nations, also play a role in the American president’s decision). The US “invasion” of Panama is also intended to send a strong message to the Red Spring-installed government in Moscow.

...

1995

Nearly six years later, trade and border disputes have strained relations between the USSR and the PRC close to the breaking point. The Krasnaya Vesna government hopes that a war with China will stoke faltering Soviet nationalism, and that the seizure of natural resources in Manchuria will save the teetering Soviet economy.

-

Rainbow Six
05-20-2023, 05:46 PM
FWIW I'm also a fan of the V1 timeline (to the virtual exclusion of all others, including V4) and I've always butterflied away the first Gulf War as never having taken place.

Raellus
05-20-2023, 05:56 PM
FWIW I'm also a fan of the V1 timeline (to the virtual exclusion of all others, including V4) and I've always butterflied away the first Gulf War as never having taken place.

Yeah, I'm still on the fence regarding the Gulf War. I used to toss it out as well, but creating an alternate timeline for '89 has got me rethinking things.

-

stilleto69
05-20-2023, 11:49 PM
I've included the Gulf War as well as Operation Urgent Fury and Operation Gothic Serpent as explanations for the increase in US defense spending as well as the overhaul of US Army light infantry units, i.e. the continuing creation of the US 9th ID (Motorized) to include LAV-75s as well as M8 Bufords.

Tegyrius
05-21-2023, 06:36 AM
I've included the Gulf War as well as Operation Urgent Fury and Operation Gothic Serpent as explanations for the increase in US defense spending as well as the overhaul of US Army light infantry units, i.e. the continuing creation of the US 9th ID (Motorized) to include LAV-75s as well as M8 Bufords.

Given the LAV-75's design intent as deployable light armor for a Middle Eastern intervention force, the Gulf War happening in-timeline is an elegant and appropriate rationalization for its in-game existence.

(It does raise the question of how a T2k with a Gulf War remains compatible with RDF Sourcebook and King's Ransom.)

- C.

Louied
05-21-2023, 10:18 AM
Does anyone remember @Webstral ‘s alternate timeline? I think I have a copy somewhere. Very similar in that the POD is 1989, the Wall doesn’t fall however the Gulf War does happen while the Soviets are putting down insurrections in the Baltics and Caucuses.

kato13
05-21-2023, 04:09 PM
Does anyone remember @Webstral ‘s alternate timeline? I think I have a copy somewhere. Very similar in that the POD is 1989, the Wall doesn’t fall however the Gulf War does happen while the Soviets are putting down insurrections in the Baltics and Caucuses.

I think this is the most up to date version.

Link
https://www.docdroid.net/2l9eEus/the-storm-in-germany-by-webstral-pdf

PDF Attachment here in case the above dies.
https://forum.juhlin.com/attachment.php?attachmentid=4571&d=1613321392

Adm.Lee
05-21-2023, 11:06 PM
This is a pretty good place to bridge from 1989 to 1995.

I'm kicking around the idea of a similar coup pre-1985, but don't let me derail the discussion here.

Raellus
05-22-2023, 02:51 PM
This is a pretty good place to bridge from 1989 to 1995.

Thanks. I figured that incorporating some of the more recognizable elements of the death knell of the Warsaw Pact and USSR, like the protests at the Berlin Wall, might help lessen cognitive dissonance for those of us T2k'ers who remember that time period, or younger T2k'ers who learned about it in school.

As someone who grew up with and still prefers the v1 History Chronology, I've been completely ignoring the IRL end of the [First] Cold War in my head canon for many years, but that hand-waving approach never quite felt right. I don't like how either v2 or 4e handled it so I decided to take matters into my own hands. I like having a temporal point- in this case a single year- that I can point to and say, "Here is where the T2kU branches off from our own." A clear, clean break, if you will.

Including the pro-democracy protests in Eastern Europe and the Baltic SSRs also creates more space for anti-Soviet Eastern European partisan and/or turncoat PCs.

I'm kicking around the idea of a similar coup pre-1985, but don't let me derail the discussion here.

No worries. There's definitely a case for placing the temporal rift earlier. Doing so in 1985 would circumvent the various pro-democracy/anti-Soviet movements that occurred late in the decade, creating a very smooth segue right into the canonical v1 timeline.

-

Raellus
03-16-2024, 12:23 PM
Given the LAV-75's design intent as deployable light armor for a Middle Eastern intervention force, the Gulf War happening in-timeline is an elegant and appropriate rationalization for its in-game existence.

(It does raise the question of how a T2k with a Gulf War remains compatible with RDF Sourcebook and King's Ransom.)

I've often thought that Saddam Hussein would not have ordered the invasion of Kuwait if the USSR, one of Iraq's main military suppliers, had disapproved*.

Then again, I've wondered whether, in an alternate timeline, if perhaps Moscow would have encouraged Saddam's plan to conquer Kuwait, hoping that it would raise global oil prices, giving the Soviet energy industry a much-needed boost. It seems plausible, but then I started looking into the USSR's IRL relationship with Kuwait, c.1990.

Apparently Kuwait was one of only two Gulf oil states to maintain diplomatic relations with the USSR. The Kuwaiti government apparently saw the Soviets as a stabilizing force in the region, and a guarantor against Iraqi or Iranian aggression. I still need some corroborating evidence but, if true, this information would lead me conclude that Moscow would in no uncertain terms dissuade Saddam Hussein as soon as the KGB became aware of his intentions (in an alternate Cold War continuation timeline).

I'm going to have to think on this some more. Maybe Hussein ignores Moscow and acts unilaterally, putting the new Soviet leaders in a bit of a pickle. What then?


*Similarly, I'm not sure if Yugoslavia would have disintegrated as violently as it did if the Soviet Union had still existed.

-