View Single Post
  #32  
Old 04-09-2012, 05:31 PM
Olefin Olefin is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Greencastle, PA
Posts: 3,003
Default

The sections that Kate is posting are

SOVIET 74TH KGB MOTORIZED RIFLE REGIMENT

Weapons: Standard Soviet small arms. Artillery support is provided by a battery of 120mm mortars and two self-propelled
122mm howitzers. AFVs are T-72s and T-80s; APCs are
BTR-70s and BMPs. The unit uses the BRDM-3 armored car.

also

SOVIET 19TH MOTORIZED RIFLE DIVISION
Weapons: Standard Soviet small arms. The 119th Tank Regiment
consists of 32 AFVs, mostly T-55s with 6 SU-130 assault
guns for long-range fire support. The divisional artillery assets
are comprised mainly of 120mm mortars, SAU-122s and
SAU-1 52s. There is also a mixed battery of BM21 and BM14
self-propelled multiple rocket launchers.

also notice that the in the below section the armored cars are not referred to as AFVs


US DETACHMENT 14, 619TH COMBAT SECURITY GROUP

The unit also has two Peacekeeper armored cars and two Commando

and also this

THE TUDEH POPULAR MOBILIZATION ARMY (PMA)

Weapons: Soviet-made small arms (mostly AKMRs) with a
few NATO weapons mixed in. AFVs are a mixture of third line
Soviet tanks (mainly T-55s) with a few captured NATO tanks
(M60A4s and Chieftains). APCs are scarce, with the infantry
either walking or riding in trucks. What few exist are usually
BTR-70s or OT-64s. The BRDM-3 is the standard armored car.
Artillery consists of 82mm and 120mm mortarsarmored cars.


Clearly Frank Frey is saying that an AFV is a tank

he makes the designation repeatedly - and he wrote the RDF as well

so that should put to rest that an AFV - for Kings Ransom and the RDF at this point as written which means they are canon as written - is a tank

that means the US Army from June of 2000 to January of 2001 received at least 35 tanks if not more to make up for any losses in that period

you can disagree if you like - but if you do then you need to treat the RDF and Kings Ransom as non-canon for saying that the US got a reinforcement of tanks - he clearly means tank with all the refernces to AFV's as tanks in Kings Ransom

not trying to force this down anyone's throat - either you believe what Frank wrote or you have to say that the module isnt canon

there arent many other choices - its one thing if he said it once - but he said it over and over and over
Reply With Quote