View Single Post
  #27  
Old 01-18-2018, 07:06 AM
Olefin Olefin is offline
Banned
 
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: Greencastle, PA
Posts: 3,003
Default

Thats Columbia not Columbus FYI

And Enterprise could never have been refit to have flown in space - it would have had to have been rebuilt almost completely

It was an atmospheric test vehicle not space capable

FYI The loss of Atlantis is incorrect by the way - the loss of one engine would not have caused them to ditch it in the Atlantic - loss of one engine during ascent means you have to abort to an alternate landing site not ditch - the person who wrote the article obviously didnt know the protocols for the Shuttle

Also given the US and Soviets continuing to have the space race Freedom would have most likely been manned and operational for sure by the war start - it was only delayed as it was due to the Cold War winding down - if that stays hot then Freedom is up there and manned - maybe not fully completed but manned for sure - if anything the start of the war with China would have definitely made them rush deployment just to get continual manned resources there

and a continuing Cold War means that they dont mothball the Vandenberg facility - and you are looking at a new shuttle as well - the only reason we cancelled the follow on to Endeavour was due to cost savings after the Cold War ended - so a V2 timeline would have no shuttles from Vandenberg and no new shuttle

V1 would have had at least one new shuttle and launches from Vandenberg

FYI all one engine failure modes (and even two engine failure modes) past Challenger lead to landing on a runway somewhere - the only ocean ditching option would have involved a failure with the strap on rockets and an engine or the shuttle being too damaged during orbit to successfully deploy its landing gear - thus the whole article should be treated as Apocrypha - and you cant have the shuttle damaged by sabotage - not after Challenger - it was checked way too much for that

But you cant really fault the author - have a feeling GDW didnt have someone who was an actual Rockwell Downey or NASA space shuttle engineer working for them

Last edited by Olefin; 01-18-2018 at 08:05 AM.
Reply With Quote