I welcome discussions on this topic, though I fear it can be a major point of contention in our little online community. Wherever possible I like to find ways to make things described in the published books make sense, rather than just throw out large parts of the designers' alternate history.
I'm among those who feel that most of the USN's fleets are gone not because of total destruction of ships but because most of the remaining ships are inoperable for a variety of reasons.
I'll be reading further responses to this thread with great interest as this topic aligns nicely with the way I like to explain things in my campaigns.
__________________
 "It is better to be feared than loved" - Nicolo Machiavelli
|