How Do You Plan to Use 4th Edition?

[Raellus]

Originally Posted by Olefin

Dont agree with you about insignificant message board - that is not what the forum juhlin is. And you can use the poll as a data starting point - FYI keep in mind that polling company's project political trends for the entire country based on samples of a few thousand people.

And they often get it wrong (e.g. 2016 US presidential election projections, both before and even on election day).

Originally Posted by Olefin

As I said there needs to be more polling done.

Absolutely. I commend you on your efforts to collect more data.

Originally Posted by Olefin

Also the kickstarter numbers only show interest in the new version of the game when it was initially pitched to raise money. The question that needs to be determined now - especially before it gets codified into book form - is did the kickstarter population get what they paid for?

Raw sales figures, and the poll here, aren't going to answer that question. To do so, you would have to specifically ask the KS backers, "did you get what you paid for?"

Originally Posted by Olefin

If the numbers here are indicative the answer is no.

Not necessarily. There are a few reasons why someone might have supported the v4 KS. Some supporters clearly wanted a game they could play right out of the box. Others may have always intended just to mine it for bits to use with earlier versions. Others may be completists, who backed v4 because the want to add it to their T2k collection, regardless of whether they intend to play it or not. Some backers may have just been curious. Additionally, some backers might not have had any expectations, vis-a-vis earlier versions (i.e. they just liked what they saw). This is purely anecdotal, but I've heard each of the first three afore-mentioned reasons cited by different forum members (or former members) who backed the v4 KS.

So, to sum up, more, better (i.e. more specific) data is definitely needed if you want answers to the questions you've posed, Olefin. In all sincerity, I wish you luck in collecting it. Please let us know what you learn (preferably by sharing the raw data).

Let's moot this. The OP is about how members here plan to use v4 (or not). The thread is starting to drift OT.

-