F-20 Tigershark - V1 versus V2.2

[pmulcahy11b]

Originally Posted by Olefin

Paul does have it in his list of aircraft for the game.

Yeah, I should probably move the F-20 to the Best Aircraft That Never Were pages.

[Olefin]

Originally Posted by pmulcahy11b

Yeah, I should probably move the F-20 to the Best Aircraft That Never Were pages.

probably the best idea - its just one of those things that are another V1 "fill in the blank that never happened" versus reality

[RN7]

Only 3 prototypes of the F-20 Tigershark were built but it was agile and competitive against some earlier versions of the F-16. But it was cancelled in 1982 long before the Twilight War broke out, so I think it was unlikely that it would ever have been brought back as it would have needed a lot of development and upgrades to make it competitive in the mid-to-late1990's.

That been said there are a load of anomalies between V.1 and V.2, with many of them stemming from RDF Sourcebook.

The French Air Force KC-110 never existed
The French Navy missile cruiser Jean Bart never existed.
The French Mirage 4000 fighter was never built accept for 1 prototype
The Iranian Air Force never used the British Tornado fighter-bomber
The Iranian Army never operated the British Challenger Tank
The Iranian Army never operated the Bell AH-1T helicopter or any version of the Cobra
The Iranian Army never operated the UH-60 helicopter
The Soviet Mi-17 transport helicopter never existed.
The US Air Force never operated the Hughes 530 helicopter
The US Navy never operated the French Brequet Atlantique
The US Navy never operated the Dutch Fokker F-27
The US Navy frigate FFG-25 USS Boone is actually USS Copeland
The US Navy frigate FFG-28 USS Copeland is actually USS Boone

[Legbreaker]

Originally Posted by RN7

The Soviet Mi-17 transport helicopter never existed.

Reality begs to differ.
http://www.military-today.com/helicopters/mi_17.htm

[RN7]

Originally Posted by Legbreaker

Reality begs to differ.
http://www.military-today.com/helicopters/mi_17.htm

That was Mi-27. Sorry typo

[pmulcahy11b]

The Iranian Army never operated the British Challenger Tank
They were all set to buy large amounts of the Challenger 1. but this deal was scotched by the Iranian Revolution. The British tried to fill Iran's immediate need for a modern tank by offering them an upgraded Chieftain; these too were cancelled by the Revolution. However, the Jordanians saw that the British had 125 tanks they had no use for, asked for a few more upgrades, and still got them at a bargain price. They call them the Shir 2.

The Soviet Mi-17 transport helicopter never existed.
Not true; the Mi-17 is a progressive improvement of thr Mi-8. I will grant you that the Iranians might not have them in T2K; it depends on how close they were to the Soviets in the T2K timeline.

The US Air Force never operated the Hughes 530 helicopter
True, but the Nightstalkers did operate then and do to this day.

The US Navy never operated the Dutch Fokker F-27
The Navy does have a few of them, but probably not in the T2K timeline.
The Army operates a good number also. They are handy jump aircraft in SOCOM, and they have found the F-27 can be modified for "additional uses."

[RN7]

Originally Posted by pmulcahy11b

The Iranian Army never operated the British Challenger Tank
They were all set to buy large amounts of the Challenger 1. but this deal was scotched by the Iranian Revolution. The British tried to fill Iran's immediate need for a modern tank by offering them an upgraded Chieftain; these too were cancelled by the Revolution. However, the Jordanians saw that the British had 125 tanks they had no use for, asked for a few more upgrades, and still got them at a bargain price. They call them the Shir 2.

The Soviet Mi-17 transport helicopter never existed.
Not true; the Mi-17 is a progressive improvement of thr Mi-8. I will grant you that the Iranians might not have them in T2K; it depends on how close they were to the Soviets in the T2K timeline.

The US Air Force never operated the Hughes 530 helicopter
True, but the Nightstalkers did operate then and do to this day.

The US Navy never operated the Dutch Fokker F-27
The Navy does have a few of them, but probably not in the T2K timeline.
The Army operates a good number also. They are handy jump aircraft in SOCOM, and they have found the F-27 can be modified for "additional uses."

The Iranian Revolution killed off all Western arms exports to Iran. The Iranians had ordered the Chieftain Mk.5 (P), Shir 1 and Shir 2 before the revolution, and the Shir-2 was reworked in Britain in the aftermath of the cancelled order and became the Challenger 1. All versions of the Iranian Chieftain tanks were unlikely to have been fitted with Cobham armour. T2K does state that Iran became more friendly with the West before the Twilight War started, but I doubt they received any Challenger I's from Britain as the British Army was building up its strength for the war in Europe and would not have been able to spare them from its already relatively limited stocks.

Mi-17 was a typo, it should have been Mi-27. The Mi-27 never existed.

The 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment (Nightstalkers ) is part of the US Army

The US Navy VOJ-24 operated 4 Fokker F-27 and 2 Brequet Atlantique as naval air units under USAF control. The Atlantique is a marine-patrol or anti-submarine aircraft and by assumption the F-27 would be the marine patrol version (F-27 200-MAR or Maritime Enforcer), as the US Navy has no real use for a troop transport like the US Army C-31A Troopship. The F-27 200-MAR was never used by any US forces.

[StainlessSteelCynic]

Originally Posted by RN7

Only 3 prototypes of the F-20 Tigershark were built but it was agile and competitive against some earlier versions of the F-16. But it was cancelled in 1982 long before the Twilight War broke out... <snip>

The information you have is incorrect, it's first flight was in 1982 and while the F-20 project was officially cancelled in 1986, it was still considered a possibility for foreign sales into the late 80s.
There is a New York Times article dated 9th May, 1989 commenting on reprimands at Northrop for attempting to sell the F-20 to South Korea.
https://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/09/b...-northrop.html

Edit: Meant to say as well that the Iranian Army did operate the AH-1J in a modified form (officially it was the AH-1J International). In 1971 the Iranians purchased 202 of them to be operated by Imperial Iranian Army Aviation (and then later by the Islamic Republic of Iran Army Aviation). While the Iranian Army did not operate the AH-1T, the -1J is of the same "Super Cobra" family. So technically they did not operate the Cobra, they operated the Super Cobra but that's really just semantics.

[Olefin]

Its one thing that was never really resolved between V1 and V2.2 - i.e. in V1 the Iranians eventually overthrew the government and put one in that was much more friendly to the West - thus the Western equipment that was operated by Iran and the fact that the US came to their aid and didnt have to fight their way ashore against a hostile Iran and a hostile Soviet Union

One thing that has always been understood is that V1 and V2.2 were basically interchangeable once the war started as to the published modules - i.e. you could use a V1 module in the V2.2 timeline you just make some changes for equipment (i.e the giraffe version of the M1 is now the M1A2 of our reality) and the change from Soviet troops in Vietnam to Soviet troops in the Kuriles (i.e. Japan is now much more directly involved in the war)

The question is did the RDF and by extension Kings Ransom still occur as is - i.e. the Iranians overthrew the revolutionary govt and re-established ties with the West - which would be a further POD from our reality beyond just Yeltsin and his guys eating it at the hands of the KGB and preserving the Soviet Union?

If so then at least the "where did the Iranians get British tanks and US helos as part of their equipment" part of the question raised above is somewhat resolved

Otherwise you have to look at a very different RDF for V2.2 - one where the US forces probably would have had to have been bigger to actually survive if they had to have fought their way onshore against the Iranians and then withstood the Soviets as well - which is not the V1 situation at all

[RN7]

Originally Posted by Olefin

Its one thing that was never really resolved between V1 and V2.2 - i.e. in V1 the Iranians eventually overthrew the government and put one in that was much more friendly to the West - thus the Western equipment that was operated by Iran and the fact that the US came to their aid and didnt have to fight their way ashore against a hostile Iran and a hostile Soviet Union

One thing that has always been understood is that V1 and V2.2 were basically interchangeable once the war started as to the published modules - i.e. you could use a V1 module in the V2.2 timeline you just make some changes for equipment (i.e the giraffe version of the M1 is now the M1A2 of our reality) and the change from Soviet troops in Vietnam to Soviet troops in the Kuriles (i.e. Japan is now much more directly involved in the war)

The question is did the RDF and by extension Kings Ransom still occur as is - i.e. the Iranians overthrew the revolutionary govt and re-established ties with the West - which would be a further POD from our reality beyond just Yeltsin and his guys eating it at the hands of the KGB and preserving the Soviet Union?

If so then at least the "where did the Iranians get British tanks and US helos as part of their equipment" part of the question raised above is somewhat resolved

Otherwise you have to look at a very different RDF for V2.2 - one where the US forces probably would have had to have been bigger to actually survive if they had to have fought their way onshore against the Iranians and then withstood the Soviets as well - which is not the V1 situation at all

The Iranians might have got some equipment but I think it would depend on the relative sophistication of the equipment and its availability.

[StainlessSteelCynic]

You're correct, the Iranians didn't use the AH-1T but that was not what I was saying. I said they operated a similar type, specifically, the AH-1J International, which they have copied to create their Toufan and Toufan II attack helicopters.
The GDW authors were incorrect to state the helo was the AH-1T but it's possible they believed that theIrianian -1J model was the -1T or even that maybe they didn't have knowledge of the -1J model and assumed that substituting it would be okay for the game. Maybe it was a typo by the printer?

We'll probably never know but as the Iranian revolution was in 1978-79 and the purchase of the AH-1J was in 1971 it's not too much to assume that deliveries were pretty much complete before the revolution so no matter what the reason, the Iranians did have a twin-engine version of the Cobra in service before the events of the game.

[RN7]

Originally Posted by StainlessSteelCynic

The information you have is incorrect, it's first flight was in 1982 and while the F-20 project was officially cancelled in 1986, it was still considered a possibility for foreign sales into the late 80s.
There is a New York Times article dated 9th May, 1989 commenting on reprimands at Northrop for attempting to sell the F-20 to South Korea.
https://www.nytimes.com/1989/05/09/b...-northrop.html

Edit: Meant to say as well that the Iranian Army did operate the AH-1J in a modified form (officially it was the AH-1J International). In 1971 the Iranians purchased 202 of them to be operated by Imperial Iranian Army Aviation (and then later by the Islamic Republic of Iran Army Aviation). While the Iranian Army did not operate the AH-1T, the -1J is of the same "Super Cobra" family. So technically they did not operate the Cobra, they operated the Super Cobra but that's really just semantics.

You are right I made another typo like I did with the Mi-27 (Mi-17!!). Sorry I was typing in a hurry

However only 3 F-20 Tigershark were ever made. Once Ronald Reagan got elected as US President in the aftermath of the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan and relaxed arms exports to Western Allies the F-20 was never really going to fly. There was interest in the F-20 from other countries but that interest faded once other US combat aircraft were available for export. The US was building the F-15, F-16, F-18 at the time and was willing to export them.

The F-20 was competitive against an F-16 powered with a PW F100 jet engine (the export model), but it lacked the range and weapons load of this version of the F-16. Against an F-16 powered by a GE F110 jet engine (the USAF model) the F-20 lost all of its aerodynamic competiveness.

Northrop was also the prime contractor for the B-2 Stealth Bomber which was being developed in the 1980's and didn't push the DOD to much about its lack of interest in the F-20.

The Iranians used the single-engine AH-1 prior to the Iranian Revolution, but not the twin-engine AH-1T as listed in RDF Sourcebook.